Print edition purchases must be purchased directly from ArtScroll or Each translation page faces Gemara page of the classic Vilna Shas; 9″ x. Print edition purchases must be purchased directly from ArtScroll or Each translation page faces Gemara page of the classic Vilna Shas; 7″ x. 7 Results Published By: ArtScroll Mesorah Publications. Release Date: 12/20/ Format : Hardcover. List Price: $2, Your Price: $2, Discount.
|Published (Last):||25 December 2010|
|PDF File Size:||15.24 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||2.88 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
November 13, 3: I mean its gotta make sense because after all, its a mefurishe Artscroll! Also practiaclly all the rashis are explained. English and French are not remotely related.
For this reason I learn in a regular Gemara and have shaas Artscroll on the side. Then go ahead and enjoy. November 10, 3: One of the most valuable qualities of AS Shas are the notes which do a lot of research on numerous points on each daf.
FULL SIZE SCHOTTENSTEIN Ed Talmud ENGLISH
My only thought to the folks here on artscrolo subject is that if two people are learning from an untranslated shas, will they already know and share all the information on any given point that is contained within an Artscroll shas?
This bothers me because I want to remember the lashon of the Gemara and the tzuras hadaf. Open the Schottenstein Edition and step into a “study hall without walls.
November 11, ArtScroll Mesorah Publications Published: November 11, 8: The goyim have a saying that translators or traitors, which is true in many ways. November 10, 2: And in your day you walked to school 3 miles uphill both ways on dirt roads and learned only from the tzuras hadaf. That being said, this argument for all of us is pointless. December 29, 9: November 14, 5: Im not saying that someone who does what you described will have less schar than others, but when learning there should be ameilus, not just having it taught to you.
Some people will bash it without knowing why. Pehaps ameilus means a guy who worked all day in Manhattan, spent 2 hours commuting, comes home and helps his kids with their homework and still makes a seder at night to learn.
November 10, 6: Yungerman — Ameilus means to toil.
Then you see Bochurim learning with artcroll they will never know how to learn if its spoon fed ameilus is the only way. French is a Romance artscrokl from which the French have attempted to bar outside influences. Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.
– FULL SIZE SCHOTTENSTEIN Ed Talmud ENGLISH
December 29, 6: Print edition purchases must be purchased directly from ArtScroll or ArtScroll. Login to your account to see if you qualify. But it also is tremendous because it breaks up the words phrase by phrase, so anyone who properly uses the Artscroll can get used to how the Shakla Vetarya goes. Very interesting discussion with many valid points raised. November 10, There are people who zrtscroll artscroll that could use it,and the people who do use artscroll become very knowledgeable while artscrol people who need it stay ignorant.
Every person who worked on the ArtScroll shas had a Steinsaltz gemara right next to him. November 10, 9: Precisely the working person should not be using AS.
Yes Art Scroll is a crutch -but some people need crutches to walk. Go ahead and use Artscroll and dont be shy about it.
Sg Precisely the working person should not be using AS. Every word of the text appears, vowelized and translated Each phrase is explained so that the reader understands the reasoning and flow Each question, answer, proof and rebuttal is introduced so that the reader will know where the Gemara is taking him Notes expand on the explanation of the Gemara’s points, and explain unfamiliar ideas without interrupting the flow of the text Detailed diagrams Introductions to the entire tractate and to each topic, wherever necessary Glossary explains key expressions in each tractate Rashi headings in bold type Each translation page faces Gemara page of the classic Vilna Shas 9″ x 12″ page size Acid-free paper Magnificent specially sculpted cover Reinforced deluxe library binding for long use Ribbon-marker The total linear measurement for this set is People who have the time to learn up a gemara by themselves and instead use an Artscroll are ripping themselves off.